Remembering the Kanji 3, Second Edition; James W. Heisig and Tanya Sienko; For the reading, about twenty-five percent of the new kanji fall into “pure. Hello, I finished to study the 1st volume of the book remembering the kanji, and I remember all the janji I learned, .but now how i should. Remembering the Kanji 3: Writing and Reading third in the Remembering the Kanji book series by James Heisig.
|Published (Last):||19 December 2008|
|PDF File Size:||10.18 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||16.30 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
To submit a translation request, visit here instead. This is not the full list of rules. Please also read the full list of rules on the wiki. Resources Heisig’s Remembering the Kanji, book 2 and 3?
For some reason the second and third iterations have hardly any reviews online, and I don’t recall seeing them talked about on this subreddit. I currently own the first book though I have yet to dig inbut RTK 2 is currently on amazon.
Remembering the Kanji III: Writing and Reading Japanese Characters for Upper-Level Proficiency
I’m aware that RTK 2 simply takes the established Kanji from 1 and teaches the readings. RTK 3 does both–it introduces new Kanji in the vein of the first book, then teaches the readings in the vein of the second. Is RTK 2 an effective way to learn the readings of knaji Kanji from book 1?
Or is there a better resource out there for the readings. I feel like the answer to this would also directly give me the answer for book 3.
Anyone have experience with either volumes 2 or 3? RTK 2 IS meant to be done alongside other study, on the other hand.
He says in the introduction that it’s quite suited to reading out of order and dipping in and out, as you need. There’s a lot of great ideas in it that will help you learn readings, in particular the signal primitives. You may notice signal primitives without his help, but his book has everything already collated into groups, whose exceptions are made clear to avoid errors.
The book also does cover compounds per kanji so that you have a basis of real words, but expects you to have a vocabulary enough to know these already and to know other examples of compounds.
RTK 2 is different from RTK 1, because it is a less novel approach and it should fit around any study approach rather than a custom one. Don’t think you won’t benefit from all the work that went into RTK 2 though, it will make your studies easier.
ksnji Book2 is not worth your time. Book 3 doesnt serve a real purpose, as you wont rely on rtk method once you need those rarer kanji.
Memorizing individual kanji pronunciation doesnt give you real benefit as you still dont know which pronunciation to go with a particular kanji combination.
Heisig’s Remembering the Kanji, book 2 and 3? : LearnJapanese
Its generally agreed to be better to learn it as you learn vocab. The reason RTK tends to be disliked on here is because you learn zero pronounciation with the first book, just some vague keywords.
In book II you learn pronounciations, however you don’t learn when to use which reading for which vocabulary, and you don’t learn when readings get shortened or rendaku’d. So basically, first you spend months not learning how to pronounce kanji and then you spend months learning readings for kanji of which you don’t have any idea when to use which. The more effective thee is to learn how kanji are pronounced in context of vocabulary, so that you learn about exceptions and get some immediate use out of it.
I agree, also, RTK is comparably haphazard to other resources. Also, the way KLC is taught seems to be more in line with scientific research on how rememnering a language works, from first principles.
RTK just tells you that you need to build up a system for remembering Kanji and that it is done by following the book and that the reason is because he says it works. Being originally knji init’s no surprise that the knowledge becomes outdated after 40 years and that more well researched resources and methodology come out to replace it.
Project MUSE – Remembering the Kanji 3, Second Edition
If you rsmembering new to learning Japanese, read the Starter’s Guide. Check to see if your question has been addressed before posting by searching or reading the wiki. Not doing so falls under ‘Low effort’ see rule 6. State your question clearly in your post title 3. Consider the OP’s skill level when answering a question.
Use furigana if you think they won’t understand your kanji usage. Do not guess or attempt to answer questions beyond your own knowledge. Trolling, immature, or hostile behavior will result in a warning hesig ban 6. The following will result in post removal: Rememberinb “How do I learn Japanese? Content creators wishing to advertise must contact the mods first. Furigana To create furigana in your posts, use the following syntax: Welcome to Reddit, the front page of the internet.
Become a Redditor and subscribe to one of thousands of communities. LearnJapanese submitted 2 years ago by whats8. Want to add to the discussion? These books is mentioned in this sub infrequently. The answer is always the same.